loving your work, this is lo-fi powerpop gold. Somewhere between Big Star and Guided by Voices. Feels like the guest harmonies should have had some (more?) of the chorus / tape kinda FX on them to help them blend with the lead a bit more, but the ramshackle feel doesn't harm the song at all, I like this lots.

This energy is great, and frankly if this song was in competition it probably would contend for a top spot this week on the basis of having that awesome energy. Like sure, there’s all kinds of flaws but this type of rock song doesn’t care about those things, so I’m sure not going to nitpick them.

Man, I wish you'd made it into round 0, I think you could have been a contender this Nur Ein! I've been really enjoying your shadows. I love this song, this would have been one of my favorites of the round if it was in competition. There are a lot of rough spots in the execution and production, but it's chock full of feeling and lo-fi charm; the guest vocals work well to give it a sense of realness and raw emotion. Those two opening(/closing) lines are so striking, I'm super into the combo of the lyrics and arrangement/performance at those spots.

A real lo-fi energy that I'm definitely into here. Some of the vocals near the start are pretty shaky pitch-wise but delivered with gusto, which makes up for it. They improve as we progress though. Some of the guitars are a little out of time occasionally but again, you've created such a distinctive mood which is often all you need to make up for the odd fluffed take.