this is a tricky one for me. I have fewer actual potentially useful criticisms than I did for the previous song, it sounds slick and solid, hits the challenge etc. But from a personal point of view this falls directly into the exact middle of a particular subgenre I absolutely cannot stand - despite the obvious craft on display this was the song I least looked forward to revisiting of the round. I know the other judges are more heavy-rock oriented than I am so I'm sure they'll balance out my ranking but I have to take into account how little I liked this song, unfortunately.

Primus. It's weird, I don't think anything is particularly bad in itself, but together, I'm not sure everything fits. Love the heavy dun dun, and the solo RIPS!, but the weird bass only verses… and the vocals that don't seem to fit in some of the sections… I don't think on a whole it works, but the pieces aren't bad in themselves. Hrmmm...