I like the rhythm. I like the vocal tone/inflection. It/they sound layered/thick and is a nice touch. I like that it is definitely an answer/response challenge-wise and seems natural. I like the one more with a feeling line/hook. I feel this would be firmly in the 80’s movie soundtrack feels if it had more pads than active guitars and rhythm. I also think I like this arrangement better even if this makes me a little nostalgic for that 80’s feel.